Father Paul arrives on Crockett Island as a replacement priest for St. Patrick's after its standing minister falls ill. From there, he builds a loyal congregation of followers after performing various miracles.
Father Paul was later revealed to be Crockett Island's original pastor, Monsignor Pruitt. He is the biological father of Sarah Gunning.
- Book I: Genesis
- Book II: Psalms
- Book III: Proverbs
- Book IV: Lamentations
- Book V: Gospel
- Book VI: Acts of the Apostles
- Book VII: Revelation